I have an embarrassing secret. And it’s not that I don’t know how to ride a bike (at this point, that doesn't even embarrass me anymore).
No…my secret is much worse than that: I love to watch food-related infomercials. This infatuation started back in middle school – before Food Network existed (even back then I loved food programming). I find the terrible acting, the general cheesiness of the product and the inevitably horrible-looking food oddly engaging. The Ronco Rotisserie Cooker? Check. The Food Dehydrator? You bet. The skillet steamer with the Dave Coulier-wannabe host? Absolutely. The Magic Bullet? One of my favorites.
Once in a great while, an infomercial product will make “the leap” into the mainstream. A prime example of this rare occurrence is the Foreman grill. I first saw George pitching this product in high school and after I graduated from college, every single male I knew owned one. And, in full disclosure, I have a Foodsaver vacuum sealer in my kitchen (Buy in bulk and save money! Great for camping!).
Then there’s the sandwich press.

In middle school, back before everyone owned expensive gourmet Panini makers, there was the humble sandwich press. In this infomercial, the host would put all sorts of ingredients between two slices of bread. Stuffed grilled cheese, cooked apples for “turnovers” and most memorably, leftover spaghetti with sauce. At the time, I was a little horrified by that last one, but I secretly wanted this machine.
So, needless to say, I was thrilled when my co-workers recently approached me to be the Tom Colicchio to their “Sandwich Press-Off” contest. The Sales Planner team in my office has an old school sandwich press like the one from the infomercial and can often be found warming their sandwiches in the kitchen, much to the envy of others eating their generic Midtown deli salads at lunch.
As a “qualified” co-worker, I was asked to judge the Press-Off on both originality and overall taste (although I grabbed my colleague to help as I was not entirely confident in my palate being the sole decision-maker). I forewarned the team of my aversion to mayonnaise and bananas, but promised that I would eat any sandwich that was made regardless of ingredients. Fortunately for me, most heeded my warning. Ironically, however, the winning sandwich for overall taste had a lemon-garlic aioli. And I even enjoyed the peanut butter, honey, cinnamon and banana sandwich that was presented.
Over the course of the Press-Off, I tasted seven savory and three sweet sandwiches (of which one consisted of two brownies with a chocolate chip cookie in the middle…and despite already eating the equivalent of three and a half sandwiches, I polished this one off). All of the sandwiches were tasty, each one bringing something unique and interesting to the sandwich press experience – ‘wichcraft could definitely take a few lessons from this team (like the turkey, cheese, pesto, avocado and tomato sandwich). Two people used marinated artichokes which added a great unexpected flavor and is an ingredient that I will definitely be including in future sandwiches.
Parts of the sandwiches we tasted. I saved a small piece of each sandwich for the final evaluation after I tried each sandwich.
The winner for originality was a sandwich pressed with Indian-spiced potatoes. After all, carbs stuffed with more carbs? Sign me up! It was like a crusty bread samosa. The only thing that could have made this even better would’ve been some chutney for a little more kick. Another favorite was the prosciutto, brie, walnut, and fig jam sandwich on buttery whole grain bread (I could see this sandwich in Gourmet magazine).
The overall winner was a rich and tangy fresh mozzarella, tomato, marinated artichoke sandwich with the aforementioned homemade lemon-garlic aioli. Yep…I ate mayonnaise…and enjoyed it. I know, I know. I'm shocked, too. I just chalk it up to the magic of the sandwich press.